Fantastic trash movie when it’s celebrating the trash part. The initial scene is a good example. Approaching Mega City 1 is so over the top and so cheaply made that it’s great. Also, the final scene with Sylvester riding away on his judge bike in his Versace costume is so ridiculous that it can’t be anything else than outstanding.
Where the movie falls short is in its action parts when it aims to match more ordinary action movies. Most notably, this is obvious in the last third when Judge Dredd hunts down Judge Rico with the chase and the fights. I ignore these parts in my rating as I love the garish comic style of the rest so much.